Quantcast
Channel: the charles smith blog
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 8447

Bulletin: Bite mark evidence: (2): Steven Chaney case: (Texas); Star-Telegram supports moratorium recommended by The Texas Forensic Science Commission in an editorial headed..." Bite mark analysis has lost its teeth"..."Bite mark analysis was brought to the commission’s attention after Steven Chaney was exonerated for a 1987 murder. Although he claimed innocence and had several alibi witnesses, a bite mark on the victim’s arm and two forensic dentists’ testimonies helped convince the jury otherwise. He served 28 years before being freed last fall. The Innocence Project submitted a complaint to the commission, which spent six months investigating it with panel of forensic dentists. The conclusion mirrored a National Research Council 2009 report, which says “no thorough study has been conducted of large populations,” and there’s no “existing scientific basis” on bite mark analysis. The commission’s sound recommendation will create better conviction integrity in criminal cases — if courts listen."

Previous: Bite-mark evidence: (1): Dallas Morning News says ban on bite-mark evidence would be a welcome step against junk science; "Shockingly, members of the American Board of Forensic Odontology, which oversees the practice of bite mark analysis, continue to defend its validity. They say it can be particularly useful as evidence in child abuse cases. But there’s no getting around the studies finding that bite-mark analysis has not stood up to scientific challenges. And consider: If this evidence is being used to put the wrong people in prison, that means the real culprits of these heinous crimes are still running around among us.........The review was prompted, in part, by the execution of Cameron Todd Willingham based on highly suspect arson science that supposedly linked Willingham to the deaths of his three daughters. The state has an obligation to track down cases where there were errors in the system, for the sake of victims and the wrongfully accused. Junk science should not be allowed to corrupt justice."
$
0
0


Read more here: http://www.star-telegram.com/opinion/editorials/article60722776.html#storylink=cpy



Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 8447

Trending Articles