Quantcast
Channel: the charles smith blog
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 8452

Susan Neill-Fraser: Australia; Last -ditch legal bid fro freedom begins in Hobart Supreme Court, ABC News reports in story headed: "Key witness says she made a false statement out of fear."..." She must convince Justice Michael Brett that there is fresh and compelling evidence to warrant a retrial. But the appeal's first witness Meaghan Vass — who was a homeless teenager at the time of the murder — said a statement she made that appeared to be helpful to Neill-Fraser's case was false. In April this year, Ms Vass, 24, signed a statutory declaration saying she was on the boat co-owned by Neill-Fraser and Mr Chappell in 2009. Her statement said Neill-Fraser was not aboard the boat. Also, the court heard Ms Vass's statement read: "I was on the Four Winds yacht and I was with people." Today, she said the entire statement was made up and she signed it out of fear. "I was threatened to be put in the boot of the car over that statement," she said. "I was too f**king scared. It is not true. I was made to sign it out of fear. "This is just something that Karen Keefe has made up." Karen Patricia Nancy Keefe has been charged with corrupting a witness and perverting the course of justice. Ms Vass repeatedly told the court she did not remember anything about the night of the murder and she did not know Neill-Fraser or Bob Chappell. "As far as I'm concerned this occasion doesn't exist," she said. "I can't remember. I don't know these people [Sue and Bob]." No body or weapon have ever been found. Neill-Fraser has always maintained her innocence and the case has attracted a high level of public interest, the story featuring as a documentary, a play and a book."

Next: James Duckett: Florida: Commentary: (Case involves discredited FBI hair matching 'expert' Michael Malone); Orlando Sentinel asks prosecutors to "test the DNA" in order to settle questions on Duckett's murder conviction...""An important piece of evidence that helped win a death sentence for rookie Mascotte Police Officer James Duckett in 1988 has since fallen apart. Yet, the Florida Supreme Court ruled earlier this month that Duckett, convicted of raping and killing an 11-year-old school girl while on duty, shouldn't get a new trial. That's too bad because questions have swirled around the case since the day the jury came back with a guilty verdict. Still, Duckett has a way to save himself from a lethal injection, but so far he hasn't taken it: DNA."...". An "expert" FBI senior agent who provided a damning piece of testimony at the trial later was discredited. Michael Malone swore that a sample of more than 20 of Duckett's hairs had "exactly the same characteristics" and were "completely indistinguishable" from the lone hair found in Teresa's panties. Later, the Justice Department's inspector general and a 2014 FBI report both declared that Malone's testimony "exceeded the limits of science and were, therefore, invalid." The inspector general report stated that Malone didn't just stretch the truth but "falsely testified" in some cases. The Supreme Court, however, concluded in its Oct. 12 opinion that jurors would not have felt the "reasonable doubt" needed to acquit Duckett even if they'd known the hair evidence wasn't on the square. Wells disagrees, and she plans to file a motion for a rehearing. "Juries listen to experts. It's the FBI — the preeminent law enforcement agency — and that's going to carry the day," she said."
Previous: Momentous Development: Larry Swearingen; Texas; The Chronicle reports that prosecutors and defence counsel have agreed to DNA testing..."After years of courtroom wrangling, lawyers from both sides are finally agreeing to move forward with DNA testing in the 1998 rape and murder of Montgomery College student Melissa Trotter. The agreement, expected to be finalized in court papers in the coming weeks, comes just days after a judge called off the pending execution of death row inmate Larry Swearingen, who was convicted in the slaying nearly two decades ago and has since repeatedly professed his innocence. "They're doing the right thing," defense attorney James Rytting said Sunday, pointing to another death row inmate's alleged plan to confess to the crime as evidence of the need for testing. A lab would likely evaluate the rape kit, the ligature used to strangle Trotter, finger nail scrapings and hair. "We're still working out the details, but I'm excited that Mr. Rytting has finally agreed to allow us to test this DNA," Montgomery County District Attorney Brett Ligon said Sunday. "I'm glad to be moving forward on this matter." Years-long legal battles over DNA testing have become a hallmark of Swearingen's case, which even sparked changes to state laws regarding post-conviction DNA testing in 2015."
$
0
0



GIST: "A key witness to the appeal bid of convicted murderer Sue Neill-Fraser said she was threatened into making a statement that cast doubt over Neill-Fraser's guilt. Neill-Fraser, 62, was jailed in 2010 for 23 years for murdering her partner, radiation physicist Bob Chappell, on board the yacht the Four Winds on Australia Day 2009. After seven years and multiple appeals, Neill-Fraser launched her last-ditch legal bid for freedom today in the Hobart Supreme Court. She must convince Justice Michael Brett that there is fresh and compelling evidence to warrant a retrial. But the appeal's first witness Meaghan Vass — who was a homeless teenager at the time of the murder — said a statement she made that appeared to be helpful to Neill-Fraser's case was false. In April this year, Ms Vass, 24, signed a statutory declaration saying she was on the boat co-owned by Neill-Fraser and Mr Chappell in 2009. Her statement said Neill-Fraser was not aboard the boat. Also, the court heard Ms Vass's statement read: "I was on the Four Winds yacht and I was with people." Today, she said the entire statement was made up and she signed it out of fear. "I was threatened to be put in the boot of the car over that statement," she said. "I was too f**king scared. It is not true. I was made to sign it out of fear. "This is just something that Karen Keefe has made up." Karen Patricia Nancy Keefe has been charged with corrupting a witness and perverting the course of justice. Ms Vass repeatedly told the court she did not remember anything about the night of the murder and she did not know Neill-Fraser or Bob Chappell. "As far as I'm concerned this occasion doesn't exist," she said. "I can't remember. I don't know these people [Sue and Bob]." No body or weapon have ever been found. Neill-Fraser has always maintained her innocence and the case has attracted a high level of public interest, the story featuring as a documentary, a play and a book. One prominent lawyer has likened Neill-Fraser's plight to that of Lindy Chamberlain. Neill-Fraser has exhausted all regular avenues of appeal but has a final chance under new fresh and compelling evidence legislation.

The entire story can be found at:

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-10-30/susan-neill-fraser-last-ditch-appeal-bob-chappell/9098224

PUBLISHER'S NOTE: I am monitoring this case/issue. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system. The Star has a "topic" section which focuses on recent stories related to Dr. Charles Smith. It can be found at: http://www.thestar.com/topic/charlessmith. Information on "The Charles Smith Blog Award"- and its nomination process - can be found at: http://smithforensic.blogspot.com/2011/05/charles-smith-blog-award-nominations.html Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com. Harold Levy; Publisher; The Charles Smith Blog.

Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 8452

Trending Articles