Quantcast
Channel: the charles smith blog
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 8450

Adnan Syed: Maryland: Bulletin: New trial ordered (once again) for subject of the 'Serial' podcast..."To corroborate his account, prosecutors presented cell phone records and expert witness testimony to place Syed at the site where Lee was buried. He was convicted in 2000 and sentenced to life in prison on murder and kidnapping charges. In 2016, a Baltimore Circuit Court judge vacated Syed's conviction and ordered a new trial, based on claims that Syed's trial lawyer failed to cross-examine the expert witness about the reliability of cell tower location evidence. The state appealed the 2016 order, leading to Thursday's decision by the court of special appeals."

Next: Ledura Watkins: Michigan: Flawed hair analysis case: Centrepiece of former Ohio Attorney General Jim Petro's commentary: "Good news, bad news for innocent people in prison."..."Other than his record-breaking incarceration, Watkins’s case was sadly familiar to students of wrongful conviction, a terrible miscarriage of justice that never should have happened. Watkins was convicted with just a hair of physical evidence, literally. One hair found on the victim reportedly had 15 similarity points with Watkins’s hair; such forensic analysis later was shown to be unreliable. A witness who said he committed the murder with Watkins later admitted that he lied. Police reports that would have discredited the witnesses against Watkins, reports that identified another suspect who failed a lie detector test, never were disclosed to Watkins’s defense, as required of police and prosecutors. Watkins is one of 139 innocent defendants who were exonerated in the United States in 2017, according to a new report by the National Registry of Exonerations."..."The bad news first: Eighty-four of the innocent defendants exonerated in 2017, including Ledura Watkins, were victims of misconduct by police, prosecutors, or both. That’s a record for a single year — a deeply distressing record considering that misconduct, by its very nature, is usually hidden. And it most often remains hidden, especially among the many wrongful convictions that we never discover. The good news is that an increasing number of elected prosecutors around the country have created “conviction integrity units” in their offices, 33 as of the end of last year. These prosecutorial units are dedicated to identifying wrongful convictions and remedying them (to the extent possible), and preventing these terrible errors. They were involved in 42 exonerations in 2017. Better yet, 16 exonerations in 2017 included cooperation between conviction integrity units and organizations that represent innocent defendants who have been convicted of crimes — such as the Ohio Innocence Project that approached me about Clarence Elkins in 2005, and dozens of similar groups around the country. That, too, is a record. But if nothing else happens, these records won’t amount to much."
Previous: False identifications: Refreshing commentary by two veteran law enforcement officials - on how police can prevent false identification by eyewitnesses..."We represent two very different communities and states: a small town in Massachusetts and a larger urban community in North Carolina. However, we know that flaws in human memory are the same regardless of where you are in the country. In both of our states, innocent people have been wrongly convicted because of a misidentification. And in both of our states, for each of those innocent men and women, a guilty person has gone free. These are terrible truths, but we must never forget them. Of the 354 DNA-based exonerations in this country, nearly three out of four involved a mistaken identification. Senate Bill 38 would mandate a scientifically proven method that would greatly reduce the chance for any future case in Louisiana, and that is why we are such strong supporters of this measure."
$
0
0

"PASSAGE OF THE DAY:  "Brown is optimistic they will get a new trial. He said he hopes the state will forgo an appeal and seek to retry the case. "If we go to trial, we will win that trial," Brown told CNN. As for whether Syed will be released on bail before a new trial, Brown told CNN: "It's something we'd consider revisiting."

-------------------------------------------

STORY:  "A court once again orders a new trial for Adnan Syed, the subject of a 'Serial' podcasts," by Jason Hanna and Alex Marquardt, published by CNN on March 29, 2018.

Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 8450

Trending Articles